Breakbulk vs. Container Shipping: Which one is right for your business?

What is Breakbulk Shipping?

Breakbulk shipping is a traditional method of shipping that involves transporting goods individually, rather than in standardized containers.

In this method, goods are loaded onto a ship’s hold, typically secured with ropes, chains, or lashings.

What is considered break bulk cargo?

Break bulk cargo refers to goods that are too large, heavy, or irregularly shaped to fit into standard shipping containers.

Break bulk cargo includes oversized machinery, construction equipment, vehicles, and other bulky items.

Why is it called break bulk cargo?

Break bulk cargo gets its name from the way it is handled and transported.

The term “break bulk” refers to the process of breaking down larger shipments into smaller units or individual items for transport.

In breakbulk shipping, goods are loaded onto a ship’s hold individually, without the use of standardized containers. Each item is carefully secured with ropes, chains, or lashings to prevent movement during transit.

Advatages of breakbulk shipping

Breakbulk shipping offers several benefits that make it an attractive option for certain types of cargo.

Here are some key benefits of breaking bulk shipping:

1. Flexibility

Breakbulk shipping allows for a wide range of cargo types and sizes to be transported.

Whether it’s oversized machinery, construction equipment, vehicles, or other large items, breakbulk shipping can handle it all.

This flexibility is particularly beneficial for industries like oil and gas, aerospace, and automotive that often deal with heavy or irregularly shaped cargo.

2. Specialized handling

Breakbulk shipping is ideal for goods that require special handling.

Fragile or perishable items can be carefully loaded and secured individually, ensuring they arrive at their destination in optimal condition.

    3. Customized handling and routing

    With breakbulk shipping, each item can be individually handled and routed to meet specific requirements. This ensures that goods reach their destination efficiently and without any compromises.

    This level of customization can be particularly advantageous for industries with unique cargo needs.

    4. Accessibility

    Breakbulk shipping provides access to ports and destinations that may not be suitable for container shipping. It allows for more flexible routes and access to remote locations.

    This can be especially important for industries operating in challenging or unconventional environments.

    5. Cost-effectiveness for certain cargo

    While breakbulk shipping can be more time-consuming and labor-intensive, it can also be cost-effective for certain types of cargo.

    The ability to transport oversized or irregularly shaped items without the need for specialized containers can save on packaging and transportation costs.

    • In summary, the benefits of breakbulk shipping lie in its flexibility, specialized handling options, customized routing, accessibility to various destinations, and potential cost-effectiveness for certain cargo types.

    What is an example of a breakbulk?

    Here are five examples of breakbulk cargo:

    1. Heavy Machinery: Breakbulk shipping is ideal for transporting heavy machinery such as cranes, bulldozers, or excavators.

    These oversized and heavy items require specialized handling and securement.

    2. Construction Equipment: Equipment used in construction projects, such as generators, cement mixers, or scaffolding, often falls into the category of breakbulk cargo.

    These items may be too large or irregularly shaped to fit into standard containers.

    3. Vehicles: Breakbulk shipping is commonly used for transporting vehicles like cars, trucks, or motorcycles.

    The size and shape of these vehicles make them unsuitable for container shipping, and individual handling is necessary.

    4. Large Pieces of Art: Artwork, especially sculptures or installations, that are oversized or have irregular shapes often require breakbulk shipping.

    This allows for careful handling and securement to ensure their safe transport.

    5. Industrial Equipment: Breakbulk shipping is commonly used for transporting industrial equipment, such as turbines, compressors, or boilers.

    These items are often large, and heavy, and require specialized handling due to their unique shapes.

    Also Read:

    What are the challenges of breaking bulk?

    Breaking bulk cargo comes with its fair share of challenges that can impact the efficiency and cost-effectiveness of shipping. Here are five challenges to consider:

    1. Time and labor-intensive: One major challenge of breaking bulk is the time and labor involved in handling individual items.

    Each item needs to be carefully loaded and secured, which can be a time-consuming process.

    This can significantly increase the time and cost of shipping, especially for oversized or irregularly shaped cargo that requires special handling.

    2. Risk of damage: Since each item is loaded individually, there is a higher chance of items being bumped, scratched, or misplaced.

    Fragile or perishable goods are particularly vulnerable and require extra care and attention to ensure their safe transport.

    3. Potential delays: Breakbulk shipping is often subject to delays due to weather conditions or other external factors.

    Inclement weather or unexpected events can disrupt the shipping schedule, resulting in missed deadlines and potential financial losses.

    4. Additional paperwork and permits: Breakbulk shipping may require additional paperwork and permits for certain types of cargo.

    This adds to the complexity and cost of the shipping process, as well as the potential for regulatory compliance issues.

    5. Lack of standardization: Breakbulk shipping lacks standardization.

    Each item requires individual handling and securement, which can lead to logistical challenges in terms of storage, transportation, and tracking.

    What is Container Shipping?

    Container shipping is a method of transporting goods using standardized containers that are specifically designed for this purpose.

    These containers are typically made of steel and come in various sizes, such as 20 feet or 40 feet in length.

    They are sturdy, weatherproof, and can be easily loaded and unloaded from ships, trucks, or trains.

    Pros and Cons of container shipping

    Container shipping has several benefits that make it a preferred option for many businesses:

    1. Efficiency: Container shipping allows for efficient loading and unloading of goods, reducing handling time and increasing overall transportation efficiency.

    2. Cost-effectiveness: By utilizing standardized containers, container shipping can help reduce packaging and transportation costs.

    3. Protection: Containers are designed to withstand harsh weather conditions, providing excellent protection for goods during transit.

    4. Intermodal compatibility: Containers can be easily transferred between ships, trucks, and trains, allowing for seamless intermodal transportation.

    5. Tracking and visibility: Containers can be tracked and monitored, providing better visibility and control over the location of goods throughout the shipping process.

    Despite its benefits, container shipping also has some drawbacks to consider.

    1. Size limitations: Containers have size restrictions, which may not accommodate oversized or irregularly shaped cargo.

    2. Inflexibility: Container shipping may not be suitable for industries that require customized handling or specialized equipment.

    3. Initial investment: Utilizing containers requires an initial investment in acquiring or renting containers, which can be a significant cost for small businesses.

    4. Limited accessibility: Container shipping is limited to ports and transportation infrastructure that can accommodate containerized cargo.

    5. Environmental impact: Container shipping contributes to carbon emissions and can have a negative environmental impact due to the need for larger ships and transportation infrastructure.

    What is the difference between break bulk and out of gauge?

    Break bulk refers to cargo that is too large, heavy, or irregularly shaped to fit into standard shipping containers.

    This type of cargo requires individual handling and securement, and is often loaded onto a ship’s hold using ropes, chains, or lashings.

    On the other hand, out of gauge refers to cargo that exceeds the dimensions of a standard container. This means that the cargo is wider, taller, or longer than the container itself.

    However, they can still be transported using special containers such as open top or flat rack.

    What is the difference between container and break bulk cargo?

    The key difference between container and breakbulk shipping is the level of standardization and handling.

    Container shipping offers a more streamlined and efficient process, while breakbulk shipping allows for customized handling and transportation of unique cargo.

    Here are some major differences between container and breakbulk cargo:

    1. Packaging and Handling

    Container shipping involves packing goods into standardized containers, whereas breakbulk shipping requires individual handling and securement of each item.

    Containers offer more protection and easier handling, while breakbulk allows for customization and special care for unique cargo.

    2. Size and Shape

    Containers have size limitations, so if you have oversized or irregularly shaped cargo, breakbulk shipping is the better choice.

    Breakbulk accommodates larger, heavier, or irregularly shaped items that cannot fit into standard containers.

    3. Efficiency

    Container shipping is known for its efficiency and cost-effectiveness.

    With standardized containers, the entire process, including loading, unloading, and transferring between different modes of transportation, is streamlined.

    Breakbulk shipping, on the other hand, can be more time-consuming and labor-intensive due to the individual handling and securing of each item.

    4. Specialization

    Container shipping is suitable for industries with standardized cargo that can fit into containers.

    Breakbulk shipping, on the other hand, is preferred for industries dealing with oversized, irregularly shaped, or specialty items that require special handling or care.

    5. Accessibility

    Container shipping offers greater accessibility to ports and transportation infrastructure that can handle containerized cargo.

    Breakbulk shipping may be limited to specific ports or require specialized facilities due to the unique handling requirements.

    Which is cheaper break bulk or container?

    Container shipping is more cost-effective as it optimizes space utilization, resulting in reduced transportation expenses.

    Additionally, container shipping offers more predictable pricing, as rates are determined based on container size rather than individual item weight or dimensions.

    On the other hand, breakbulk shipping can be more expensive due to its individual handling and securing requirements.

    Each item needs to be carefully loaded and secured, which can be time-consuming and labor-intensive. This can result in higher shipping costs, especially for oversized or irregularly shaped cargo.